GuideSelling on marketplaces
How do you set holiday return rules on your Shopify store in 2026?
How to set your Shopify return rules for the 2026 holidays: where the settings are, what a return window and a restocking fee do, a longer window for gifts, how many gifts come back and the listing fixes that cut returns.

On this page
A shopper buys a pair of children's shoes from your Shopify store on 14 December. They arrive on Christmas Eve and do not fit. Your return rules decide what happens next, and you set them in your Shopify admin, under Settings, then Policies, then Return and cancellation rules.
This Guide shows what to set before the holidays, why a longer window helps gift buyers, how many gifts come back, and the listing fixes that stop a gift becoming a return.
Where do you set return rules on Shopify?
Your return rules set the window, the return shipping fee and any restocking fee. Set them in your Shopify admin under Settings, then Policies, then Return and cancellation rules. Changes apply only to future orders, so set your holiday rules before the orders arrive.
A restocking fee is a charge for taking a returned item back into stock. The return window is the span of dates a buyer has to send something back. A longer window over the holidays reassures gift buyers. If you offer one, write the last return date in full in your policy and in the product description.
What your Shopify return rules set
The three settings, and where to find them.
- WindowHow long buyers have
- A longer window for gifts, set on a collection
- ShippingThe return shipping fee
- Charged or free, as you choose
- RestockingAny restocking fee
- For taking an item back into stock
Can you give gifts a longer return window?
Yes. If you usually allow 30 days from delivery, add a return window override with a longer window on your gift collection for the holidays, so shoes delivered in December can still come back in late January.
How many holiday purchases come back?
The National Retail Federation and Happy Returns expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned in 2025. For you, that means about one gift in six comes back in January. Plan cash, space and time for it.
Why are gifts returned, and how do listings cut returns?
A gift comes back when the item is not what the buyer expected when they chose it for someone else. In Salsify's 2025 survey, 71% of shoppers had returned items over inaccurate descriptions, and 54% had dropped a purchase because of conflicting information.
Fix the listing where the questions start:
- Size, shown. A photo in a hand or beside a familiar object, and the dimensions near the top of the product page.
- Colour, true. Daylight, no filters, and a photo of every colour you sell.
- What arrives. An image of every piece in the box.
- One set of facts. The title, description, images and options must agree: the same size, the same colour names, the same count.
How do you get ready for January returns on Shopify?
- Open your return rules under Settings, then Policies, and check the window, the shipping fee and any restocking fee.
- Add a longer window for your gift collection.
- Write the last return date in your policy and on each gift product.
- Record every return reason by product, in one sheet.
- Fix the product page behind any reason that repeats, before the next season.
Our Guide to BFCM on Shopify covers the sale that brings the orders in, and our Guide to closing your Shopify store for the holidays covers the break.
Your questions, answered
Where do I set return rules on Shopify?
In your Shopify admin, go to Settings, then Policies, then Return and cancellation rules.
Do changes to my Shopify return rules apply to old orders?
No. Changes apply only to future orders.
Can I charge a restocking fee on Shopify?
Yes. Your return rules can set a restocking fee as well as the return shipping fee and the window.
How much of holiday sales are returned?
Retailers in the National Retail Federation and Happy Returns 2025 report expected 17% of holiday sales to be returned.
Why do gifts come back?
Mostly because the item was not what the buyer expected. In Salsify's 2025 survey, 71% of shoppers had returned items over inaccurate descriptions.


